Is Ichika Nito Fake? A Breakdown of the Viral “Guitar God’s” Alleged Miming

In the world of online guitar virtuosos, few names are as recognizable as Ichika Nito. Known for his crystalline tone and impossibly complex playing style, he has amassed millions of subscribers and established himself as a modern “guitar god.” However, a viral video by Jacobra Records titled “I prove Ichika Nito is the ultimate FAKE guitarist” challenges this status, presenting a compelling case that the viral star mimes his videos to pre-recorded audio.

Here is a detailed breakdown of the evidence presented in the video, analyzing the claims that challenge the authenticity of YouTube’s favorite math-rock guitarist.

The Core Allegation: Studio Magic vs. Reality

The exposé’s primary argument is that while Ichika Nito is a talented composer, his viral videos are not live performances. Instead, they are likely punch-in recordings (recorded in small sections) that are stitched together, with Ichika miming along to the perfect audio track for the camera.

The video highlights that this practice creates an unrealistic standard for aspiring guitarists, as the audio perfection heard on YouTube does not match the physical mechanics shown on screen.

Key Evidence of Miming

The video analysis provides dozens of specific examples in which the audio and video do not sync. Here are the most damning categories of evidence found:

1. The “Ghost” Sustain

One of the most frequent errors pointed out is the sustaining note discrepancy. In numerous clips, Ichika is seen lifting his fingers off the fretboard or letting go of a chord shape, yet the audio continues to ring out clearly.

• Example: At multiple points, low bass notes continue to sustain in the audio even after Ichika has visibly removed his hand or muted the string to move to the next position.

2. Phantom Vibrato and Bends

A major tell in guitar playing is the physical motion required to create pitch changes.

• Vibrato Mismatch: The audio often features wide, expressive vibrato, while Ichika’s hand remains perfectly still on the fretboard.

• Missing Bends: The analysis points out moments where the audio features a string bend, but visually, Ichika simply frets the note without bending it. Conversely, there are moments where he visually bends a string, but the pitch in the audio remains flat.

3. Physical Impossibilities

The breakdown catches several moments where the mechanics of the guitar contradict the sound produced:

• Wrong Frets: There are instances where Ichika visually lands on the wrong fret (e.g., hitting the 16th fret when the audio is playing the 15th), yet the audio remains flawless.

• Muted Strums: The video highlights moments where Ichika’s strumming hand barely grazes the strings—or misses them entirely—yet the audio produces a loud, aggressive strum.

Live Performance vs. YouTube Content

A critical part of the argument compares Ichika’s polished YouTube shorts to his actual live performances, specifically his appearance at NAMM 2022.

The difference is described as stark. While his YouTube content is flawless and machine-like, the live performance footage shows a guitarist who, while competent, struggles with intonation, timing, and cleanliness when playing complex passages without the safety net of studio editing.

The video argues that this discrepancy proves the YouTube clips are heavily engineered products rather than honest displays of skill.

The Verdict: Composer or Fraud?

It is important to note that the video does not claim Ichika Nito cannot play guitar at all. It acknowledges him as a great composer with a unique ear for melody. However, the conclusion is that he uses “studio magic”—likely recording at slower speeds or stitching together hundreds of takes—to present an image of technical perfection that he cannot replicate live.

Why This Matters

For the guitar community, the distinction between “music video” and “live playthrough” is vital. The video argues that by presenting mimed clips as raw talent, influencers like Ichika Nito set unattainable standards that can discourage learning, leaving players wondering why they can’t sound perfect every time.

Let us know in the comments section below your thoughts on this. Is this faking? Or is this just an artist miming along to their original performance?

This article may contain affiliate links to Andertons, DeathCloud,Donner,Fender, Gear4Music, Positive Grid,Sweetwater, and Thomann that help finance the running costs of GuitarBomb.  We will receive a small commission if you buy something through these links. Don’t worry; you pay the same price, and it costs you no extra to use these affiliate links for your purchases.